10-Uncharted really is this generations Tomb Raider
After hearing that sentence being thrown around quite a bit in the past few years I can finally say that I agree- Uncharted is this generations Tomb Raider. Tomb Raider slowly lost its magic after the first trilogy and I can only hope that Uncharted won’t go that way as well. If it goes go beyond a trilogy, that is. But the vacuum that Lara Croft has left has surely been replaced by Nathan Drake. All I know is that I have the same feeling for Drake than I had with Lara all those years ago. No, not that feeling you sick bastard! The feeling that upon each of his outings I’m safe in the knowledge that I’ll be whisked away to incredible locations, interact with finely written characters and basically just have a great time, the essence of a true adventure. You can rest now, Lara, you can rest now.
That said, lets not count her out just yet as next year sees an entire reboot of the Tomb Raider franchise. Time will tell though if Lara can reclaim her throne once again.
9-Uncharted does checkpoints perfectly
Good old checkpoints. Far too many games get checkpoints wrong or don’t do them entirely. A few of the games in the past few years that have done them absolutely perfectly have been Modern Warfare 2, Mass Effect 2 and Uncharted in my mind joins those ranks. In Uncharted Naughty Dog has placed the checkpoints at perfect moments throughout the game whereby with other titles I’ve felt cheated by the game for dropping me back further than I should have. It’s something in gaming that is sadly overlooked by many developers but Uncharted hits the nail on the head. Also, kudos to Naughty Dog for the uber short loading times when you die.
Because lets be honest, we’ve all played those games where a checkpoints loads as your character is falling down a hole or on the brink of death.
8-I should have played them sooner
This goes without saying, right? Yes, I should have played it sooner. Why didn’t I? I don’t really know to be perfectly honest with you. I can say it’s partly because there was such a buzz around it that it kind of put me off starting them. Maybe I just simply heard too much about it that it kind of soured them, I guess. Well, now I’m neck deep in the Uncharted saga and absolutely loving it. It reminds me of some of the old platform games on the original Playstation in terms of truly evoking a sense of adventure, something that I feel has been lacking from games of late.
So, much like many of you, I’m waiting to get my grubby paws on Drakes Deception. However, sadly due to my “can’t really focus on multiple games at the same time” syndrome it will have to wait until Skyrim is finished. Don’t worry, Drake, I’ll get to you sometime in February 2012! Then again, roll on Uncharted for the PS Vita too!
7-It was always going to be Elena
Even before Chloe came into the picture in Among Thieves I always knew it was going to be Elena that Drake would end up with. Elena is to Drake as Marrion Ravenwood is to Indiana Jones. She’s the perfect counter balance for Drakes personality and even during their first scene together I knew she’d be sticking around throughout the trilogy. Both of them have superb chemistry together on screen and a large part of that is down to their mo-cap/voice actors, Emily Rose and Nolan North.
Chloe was the wrench -a very sexy wrench that is- that was thrown into the works to test Drake and Elenas relationship. But it was always going to be Elena for Drake and I learned that right from the get-go. Lets just hope they both make it through Drakes Deception in one piece, eh?
6- Nathan Fillon shouldn’t be Nathan Drake
Alright, this is something I thought long and hard about. Before playing Uncharted no less than a month ago I heard fans crying out that Mark Walhberg was signed on to play Drake and that Nathan Fillon was their personal overwhelming pick. The internet was on fire with fans writing articles and starting petitions to try and get Nathan Fillon on board with the project. Firstly, Mark Walhberg isn’t the right choice. Sorry Marky Mark, as much as I think you’re quite a good actor you’re not Nathan Drake. Sorry. In fact, you’re not Max Payne either but that’s a different rant all together. However, I don’t agree that Nathan Fillon is Drake either.
If the creators of the films are tying to be accurate to the game and start off an ongoing franchise – choosing Nathan Fillon wouldn’t be a good choice. Why? He’s too old. Now, calm down everyone. Nathan Fillon is only 40 and while that is absolutely not “old” he’s far too old to portray Drake. Nathan Drakes age (as far as I can see) hasn’t been revealed but I’d put him in at around 28 in Drakes Fortune. Personality wise Fillon does indeed resemble Drake but I don’t think that’s enough. I suggest they try and find a somewhat unknown actor in his late twenties much like they did with Henry Cavil in the upcoming The Man of Steel.
Who should play Elena, Sully and Chloe? I’m not quite sure but I’d say Elenas voice actor, Emily Rose, would be perfect for her. Make it happen.
5- LA Noire facial animation tech isn’t the future
In the run up to LA Noire it was hard not to see the technology they used for capturing the actors facial performances as something less than spectacular. Still, even now it’s a truly stunning tech and works wonders when utilized in LA Noire. However, many gamers did and still do see it as the future of facial animation. While Uncharted didn’t exactly change my mind about keeping traditional animation- I was always of this opinion- it did reinforce it quite a bit. The facial animation in Uncharted is brim full of character, charm and wit. To me it would be more in line with Disney animation compared to ultra realistic animation. Naughty Dog aren’t afraid to over-animate their characters and give them a little bounce in their step. I’d chalk this down to Naughty Dogs history of working on the Crash Bandicoot and Jak series. Also, if the tech used in LA Noire was used in Uncharted we’d lose that charm that the characters hold over us that is so very important to the series.
It may be the future in gaming when the game hinges of decision making from looking at somes face, but Uncharted proves it isn’t the way to go for everyone else.
4-More games should give hints
Hints! Why do so many gamers look down on hints? Maybe it’s because a large amount of gamers want to be punished when playing games as if they woke up in an Turkish prison. Well, not for me, son. No thank you. I loved the fact that in both Uncharted games, no matter where you were during the game, every once in awhile an indicator will tell up to press up on the d-pad for a hint. Then the camera swings in that direction and gives you a general idea of what to do next. There’s been plenty of games in which after getting stuck at a certain point I just give up. Then again, that’s not saying Uncharted is particularly hard but it’s nice to have a hint if you need it.
So I welcome hints in games. Maybe hints won’t exactly work for every type of game but when game play hinges of solving puzzles it’s always a helpful addition.
3- Not all developers are afraid of colourful and vibrant games
During my first half hour of playing Drakes Fortune I thought, “I haven’t seen a game this colourful in a long time”. You see, I’m only too used to seeing games like Gears of War and Killzone with their saturated, dark and uninspiring colour pallete so when presented with the lush South American forests of Drakes Fortune to the beautiful and ancient peaks that hold the secret of Shambhala in Among Thieves it’s quite a treat. Naughty Dog aren’t afraid to bombarded the player with colourful and vibrant tones. Even when the player is thrown into the urban environment of the Valley of the Temples the game remains almost brash in its use of strong, thick and ballsy colour tones. Lovely.
There are far too many games that have opted for realism at the expense of colour. Thankfully, Uncharted doesn’t do that. Thank you, Naughty Dog, thank you!
2- The Xbox 360 could handle Uncharted
This point will no doubt stoke up the ever burning fanboy fires but here it goes- the Xbox 360 could handle both Uncharted games. Yes, both Uncharted games look truly incredible and Among Thieves in particular is probably one of the finest games I’ve ever seen but lets not go nuts, guys. If, for some bizarre reason, Naughty Dog were even able to bring Uncharted to the Xbox360 they easily could. This is why I always find the fanboy war silly as both systems are pretty much identical in many ways. While Uncharted does look fantastic I just don’t see why it couldn’t be done on the Xbox 360, sorry.
However, that will never happen as Naughty Dog are owned by Sony. Naughty Dog are probably the most creative and inspiring company Sony currently has in their hands and fingers crossed they keep it that way.
1- Uncharted 3: Drakes Deception will be incredible
Another thing I quickly became aware of is that Uncharted 3: Drakes Deception will no doubt be incredible. While I’ve stayed away from most of the gameplay videos and trailers out there I can’t see how Naughty Dog can mess it up. Drakes Fortune was a wonderfully inventive experience while Among Thieves surpassed my expectations by a mile. Naughty Dog seem to be on a roll here and as long as Amy Hennig is attached to the project I’ll be there in line on the first day.
I’m just hoping that, much like Among Thieves, Drakes Deception shakes it up a bit with more diverse and interesting settings and locations. That said, lets try and keep the game around the locations we want- temples, jungles and lost ancient cities!











any PS3 game can be done on the 360. it just wont be the same expirience as what it would be on PS3. i dont really know all the science behind it, but the amount of processing in the games requires a greater hardware than what the 360 is built out of. take battlefield 3 for example, isnt the 360 version lacking the PS3 version due to hardware limitations? and isnt the PC versions of games supirior over consoles games due to hardware limitations as well? granted, i %100 belive the first uncharted game can be run on the 360 as an exact port. however i think uncharted 2 would need to be dumbed down a little bit here and there in for it to run on 360. if im not mistaken wasnt GTA4 and FF13 dumbed down on the 360 too? everything is really just limited to hardware
Until 360 comes out with a game that looks and plays like the Uncharted games I won’t believe it. Even the water in Uncharted One blows away everything I’ve seen on the 360. Compare Infamous to Prototype- its just obvious which system can bring the greatness of a game out.
#2 is wrong, has nothing to do with fanboyism, it came out of Naughty Dog’s mouth that it couldn’t run on 360. How/Why I have no idea, that’s a question for them if you interview them. Maybe it could but the graphics would be toned down? Idk. But Suckerpunch said the same thing about Infamous 2.
But congrats on finally playing them. And if you guys haven’t you have to play both. Uncharted 2 is better than 1 but just barely. Uncharted 1 is a whole different experience. The game is loke $10-20 now. UC2 sold a couple million more than UC1, everyone should play both.
I believe every single point, except for UNCHARTED being possible on the Xbox 360, uncharted 1, maybe, because look! uncharted: golden abyss is on PS Vita, and the Vita’s hardware is less “hi-tech” than the 360, so yes, it can indeed be accomplished.
But Uncharted 2 gets me worked up on, it may be possible, but the experience won’t be complete, ask Naughty Dog for the reason of this, as they themselves said this, and as you said, they are the “MOST inspiring” studio of this generation (it’s an opinion, NOT FACT!), but I can’t say I disagree, but if they were the most inspiring studio of this generation, they can’t be lying by saying that Uncharted 2 is NOT possible on the 360, they’ve said it themselves lool (no offence intended), so that point kinda failed
P
Aye, Elena is, was, and will always be The One. She’s the one you can take home to your parents. Chloe is the one you keep to yourself for a weekend
The 360 probably could do these games, but it would be quite a stretch for it. I think the guaranteed Bluray and hard drive combination are the biggest advantages the PS3 gives developers over the 360. Funny how you never, ever hear about 360 games that ‘Couldn’t be done on the PS3′ though. Tells you something…
Hi guys. First off, thanks for comments. @xxx I don’t think any of the games you’ve mentioned have been dumbed down at all. But I agree that IF Uncharted made its way to the 360 it might well need to be “dumbed down” slightly. It might, just might, because from where I’m standing I really don’t see a game that is bounds above what the Xbox360 is capable of. This isn’t a criticism of the PS3 but rather just an observation I made upon playing through both Uncharted games.
@cougardue Thanks for the comments, mate. First off, I always found the comparisson between Prototype and Infamous a little flimsy. In that respect I could compare Saints Row with GTA4 just because they’re sandbox games and Modern Warfare 2 and Duke Nukem because they’re FPS’s. With Infamous and Prototype I think you need to look at the developers and what they’re putting into the product rather than the system they’re running on. Yes, a great system can indeed bring greatness out of a developer in terms of what it can handle but again, much like Uncharted, I truly don’t see what Infamous has that the Xbox couldn’t handle. And don’t get me wrong, I don’t say this as a fanboy or as someone who has made an allegiance to a certain brand. I own both systems and find all that type of fanboyism quite silly. I enjoy my PS3 as much as my Xbox. Oh and I’d be inclined to say that the water effects in From Dust blows away anything I’ve seen on both systems so far.
@Balram, thank you for the comments. All I can say is that Naughty Dog wouldn’t really be in the business of saying that Uncharted could be done on the Xbox. That’s not just good PR from their point. Thanks for the comments everyone. It’s good to get some constructive criticism. However, I did find it odd that everyone on N4G picked apart only one of my points and totally missed the other nine that pretty much praised the games, the actors and Naughty Dog for one of the most fun and adventurous games of the past decade. A shame. But at the end of the day that one point went close to the bone but I thank you guys for being civil about it.
@Hm, I agree, she IS the one. I agree about never hearing about games the PS3 “can never do”. It is quite telling I must say but I truly am of the opinion that if Microsoft owned Naughty Dog and treated them in the same way Sony have they could do Uncharted 2 for the Xbox. If the tables were reversed, I mean. But then again, Sony have a knack for not meddling with companies like Naughty Dog. I mean, look at Media Molecule and Sucker Punch! But at the end of the day this all comes down to Naughty Dog and not Sony. This comes down to their dedication and love for their work. If the tables were turned and they put the same love into an Xbox bound Uncharted as they did with the PS3 I think it would have ended up the same.
As expected, there are tons of comments that disagree with point #2. The simple fact is that both systems are essentially equal in power. There’s nothing tangible that we could use to compare, such as polygon counts, or special effects. Uncharted does not use effects, or a polygon count that can’t be done on 360.
not trying to start an arguement here but how many of you are in a position to say ps3 games can be played on the xbox i mean how many of you actually wrote the coding for these ps3 exclusives, im not saying they can’t im just saying don’t go talking about things that you don’t know about makes you look like an ass
You forgot about Nate’s fashion. The half-tucked shirt. That one is cool. XD
Just the polish of Infamous is much better than Prototype. I really think you get a game that is not up to the same level if you put it on 360. Tell me any game that had snow effects likes uncharted2 on 360. Besides the very obvious fact that blu-ray stores more, there is no way Uncharted could come out on 360.
Uncharted will never happen on 360 because Sony owns the IP.
Naughty Dog are pretty irrelevant in that argument.
To say that every PS3 game is possible on xbox is like saying “I can put an extra small t-shirt without being it tight“. It`s true that 360 and ps3 have almost the same power but the difference between these two is the fact that ps3 can play blu-ray and that`s a HUGE advantage. Why? Because there`s more content to put in a single disc!!! The only reason why triple A titles such as GTA4 or other multi-platform games can be possible on 360 is because they have been dumb down due to space restriction!!! Who cares about graphics? So xbot fanboys should grow up and move onto the real next-generation gaming. Kinect that!!!
First off; GREAT article Retro! Although I’m never going to fully accept Drake, as I grew up with Lara!!!
@xxx “isnt the 360 version lacking the PS3 version due to hardware limitations?” – The console versions will be exactly the same, the PC version will be higher quality for obvious reasons, and especially with 64 players online!
I would also like to point out that each console has it’s own strong & weak points. I wouldn’t say one is better than the other, they are both excellent in their own ways. Be thankful we have such a great choice of systems & games to chose from!
The author of the article has obviously confused graphical power with technical power. Sure, the 360 can have a game that looks like Uncharted, but it can’t have a game where an entire level takes place inside a building while it is collapsing with full physics, dynamic cover, etc. If it could, it would have been done. But it hasn’t…because it can’t. It has nothing to do with fanboyism. The hardware IS different…vastly different.
When Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune first came out an article comparing each character to a real-life actor was published. And if you ever watched the series: “FireFly,” or the movie “Serenity,” then you would quickly match Nathan Fillion (Which btw you have a typo in his name) to Nathan Drake. I can agree that his voice may be a bit higher pitched, but he seem’s to have that act of witty, evasive, cocky, yet joking voice down. He really fits the role of Nathan Drake. That is why we want him to play the role of Nathan Drake. He almost looks like Nathan Drake. Hell his first name is the same. I just wonder why he didn’t voice him in the first place. However I think the Voice Actor, Nolan North, of Nathan Drake should have been a first pick seeing how he already has the voice down, and he looks somewhat similar to Nathan Drake himself as well. But Mark Wahlberg? He was awesome in shooter, but that is it… That is the only movie I can say he did an awesome job in. As for Max Payne…. He did fine.
The 360 needs a game that is similar to Uncharted. They really are missing out on a lot if they do not own a PS3. But the problem with everyone on the 360 is… unless a game has a gun ***WITH*** an online multi-player… Then they don’t care for the game. It is truly that simple. If a game released on the 360 without any type of online mode then it will never top Bioshock. Not even Viva Pinata.
As for the graphic ability of the 360? I believe re-creating Uncharted on the 360 would take longer than it did on the PS3 to match the exact same display of 720P. Most 360 games are not in true high definition. 6 processors vs 3. And fanboys will try to use the L2 cache response…. Why does Uncharted look so damn good if the PS3 has less L2 Cache? Why is it that KillZone 2 and 3 can handle more than 70 *dynamic light sources? Why can’t the water in 360 games shimmer? The PS3 seems to handle certain aspects in graphics a lot better than the 360 when a dev truly learns the Cell Processor.
(Yes I am basically saying that a majority of 360 developers are lazy. 3XAA doesn’t mean anything if it is not a true HD resolution.)
But that doesn’t mean 360 developers will not try to out do the graphics seen on other platforms. They come close but every time I see a 360 game there is just this level of blur that I can not help but notice. I just can not stand looking at it all the time. Some games are too blury while some are just fine. I just hate it when they try to hide it.
@tim larkin
you said
“Uncharted does not use effects, or a polygon count that can’t be done on 360.”
And you know this how? Its irritating how people can say what a console “could handle” despite the company of the product who said themselves that it was impossible. Im sure Naughty Dog didn’t simply say, “it couldn’t be done” for simple PR purposes.
I dunno what this trend is with websites clamoring for Uncharted 360 love. The past month its been a multitude of websites with the same message.
My 2 cents. The Uncharted games are possible, so what blu-ray is bigger it could just go on multiple discs, especially with Uncharted as it’s such a linear game. It would never happen though. And comparing Infamous with Prototype is ridiculous, compare like for like, Prototype PS3 version with the Xbox 360 version. I don’t care either way anyway, I have both and like both. Oh and PC is greater than all but no way would I want to be in the elitest, no friends in real life, pigeon hole.
It’s been well documented that Xbox 360 has about half the processing power of PS3 (1 TFLOP vs 2 TFLOPS – Don’t argue with me look it up). I am sure the 360 could handle the graphics, I am not sure about some of the effects and animation routines. Also the 360 would require a disc change and no one likes that.
Wow. Lots of comments – I’m probably gonna be repeating somebody…but apparently, the reason the XBox controller won’t do the trick, is the Six Axis. Albeit the Six-Axis has a small part to play, Naughty Dog are naturally loyal to Sony – considering everything they’ve ever done was for Sony – so they probably intended to upsell the Six Axis. And for my fan boy opinion – the PS3 has much tougher hardware than the XBox 360. Look no further for proof than L.A Noire. I’d be one to think that Uncharted has equal, if not more power. XBox would be screwed like a pooch.
Yeah it could be done on 360. And it would be called UNREALcharted, it will be bland and it will look like all the other games out there but just like Enslaved was to Heavenly Sword, it will take a huge hit in what a current gen game should look like, all because of the “power of Unreal” thank you for that.